Suicide Terrorism - Free Essay Example

Sample details Pages: 5 Words: 1398 Downloads: 9 Date added: 2019/07/03 Category Society Essay Level High school Tags: Suicide Essay Did you like this example? During my research with these four articles, I found that they all ask one important question. My research was about suicide terrorism, and the four articles are going to help explain my point. That one question is: why are suicide bombers considered as heroes and why do they get so much praise for what they do? Throughout the paper, I am going to weave these four articles to help answer the question I find so important throughout each of the the four reading. In the first article written by Mia Bloom, Palestinian Suicide Bombing: Public Support, Market Share, and Outbidding, she asks one question. Throughout the article, she tries to answer why the opinion of Palestinians support suicide bombers. Bloom talks about how suicide bombings were intermittent and intended to undermine legitimacy of Palestinian authority as well as to negatively affect peace process (Bloom, 66). After the year 2000, the support for suicide bombers jumped tremendously in terms that groups did it to show power. Since Palestinians lives did not change near November 2000, Islamic Jihad as well as Hamas started a new type of violence were they would carry out missions of martyrdom operations to up their profile as well as win external donor support (Bloom, 69). During this time, it was getting major support from the public about martyrdom attacks and continued to increase over the next two years. Basically, this article talks about Palestinian organizations use suici de bombers to gain an edge over government because they were not getting what they wanted. They felt that they were not peaceful negotiations, so they took matters into their own hands and turned it into violence: suicide bombings. But we have yet to answer the question from this article, and according to Bloom she states that people chose to commit these bombings is because of fanaticism and despair (Bloom, 80). As within the other three articles, these bombers tend to be lower class citizens with few opportunities. Don’t waste time! Our writers will create an original "Suicide Terrorism" essay for you Create order In Hafezs article, Rationality, Culture, and Structure in the making of Suicide Bombers: A Preliminary Theoretical Synthesis and Illustrative Case Study, he also talks about and tries to understand why suicide bombers blow themselves up and are considered heroes when they do these acts. Throughout Hafezs piece, he gives different examples similar to what the other authors believe make people want to become suicide bombers. He talks about people wanting to do it for personal reasons because they feel as though their life does not start until the after life as well as religious reasons and traditions. He talks about two parts of suicide terrorism, rationalist and culturalist (Hafez, 167). Rationalist terrorism is like thinking rationally, you do things that you believe are the best way to handle certain situations. Culturalist terrorism is like doing things for a purpose and fulfilling what someone believes is the best way to handle certain situations, such as suicide bombings. Also in Hafezs article, he mentions that suicide bombers do this because of personal reasons. He also gives statistics of when suicide bombings became popular as well as how it started and how much it increased in terms of percentage, which is an extremely high number. Him and Bloom are similar when they each state that support for suicide bombings can be because of negotiating processes in terms of Palestinians. In Brym and Arajs article, Palestinian Suicide Bombing Revisited: A critique of the Outbidding Thesis, the authors talk about how social scientists argued that numerous factors motivate the outbreak of waves of Palestinian suicide attacks. This article plants different hypothesis and then gives an extensive amount of information to try and answer that hypothesis. Brym and Araj use Mia Bloom and her arguments for suicide bombers and they really try to disprove her findings. Suicide bombing hit a major uproar in terms of support in late 2000. This was increased due to people not supporting the Fatah as much as they used to be as well as the support for Hamas, which increased compared to the Fatah. Along with the other two articles, this article believes that suicide bombings are due to bad negotiations, for revenge and also to win support. The authors also use other sources throughout the paper to prove their point. I am convinced by the authors arguments because they use outside sourc es to help prove their point throughout the paper, as well as use tables and diagrams showing statistics to also help prove the point they try and get across. In the last article, From Columbine to Palestine: A comparative analysis of rampage shooters in the United States and volunteer suicide bombers in the Middle East by Lankford and Hakim, the article talks about the difference of rampage shooters and suicide bombers. In this article, it talks about how each are viewed in their respective countries as well as some of the similarities between the two. Rampage shooters are termed as troubling people with mental issues but if you look at people in the Middle East and suicide bombers, they get looked at a good people who things for their families sake and because of Religion. All though they get looked at differently, they also are somewhat similar in how they have troubled backgrounds and also troubled childhoods for that matter (Lankford Hakim, 102). As crazy as it seems that one of these groups of people get praised and the other group gets looked at differently, they do share same principles and I think that obviously we are a differen t country than the Middle East but to think that two horrendous acts can be treated as such is somewhat mind-boggling. Personally, I am convinced by the authors argument. I would say that I am convinced because of how the two acts are treated. For example, Suicide bombers in the Middle East are praised and loved for carrying out their role, whereas rampage shooters are looked at as weird and mentally ill people. The different perceptions between the two along with the examples used help ensure my certainty that I am convinced that the authors arguments are correct. Finally, I think that all four articles can tail back to my main point, and that is asking why do suicide bombers get considered as heroes as well as getting praise for what they do. The articles each give an explanation as well as having some of the same thoughts as other articles. Main reasons why suicide bombers get praise is because they do it out of Religion. Not only do they do it out of Religion, but they also want to leave a lasting mark on earth. To Palestinian suicide bombers, living on earth is just simply setting you up for the future. They believe that their life doesnt actually start until after their time on earth. Becoming a suicide bomber is simply a calling for them, and something that they need to do or they will be considered going against God. Along with becoming suicide bomber and being considered a hero, they also get looked at differently compared to what the United States think of rampage shooters. That question is still left up for grabs as why they would be considered different in their terms, but in our terms we believe that they are both wrong and there is no justifying it. Overall, I thought the four articles were very interesting and telling at the same time. Out of the four articles that I have read, I believe that Hafezs article Rationality, Culture, and Structure in the Making of Suicide Bombers best explains the question in common. Hafezs article best represents what these four articles are trying to talk about. He has strong points as well as important statistics to back up what he believes why people want to become suicide bombers. If I had to base it off who did the second best explaining it, I would personally say that Blooms article Palestinian Suicide Bombing: Public Support, Market Share, and Outbidding would be my second choice in terms of who I thought explained why people chose to become suicide bombers. If there was one that I thought was different and more harder to understand, it would be Brym and Arajs article Palestinian Suicide Bombing Revisited: A critique of the Outbidding Thesis. This was harder to try and pinpoint exactly what the article was trying to do other than find hypothesis ideas from Mia Bloom and then debunk her findings.

Natural Born Killers Essay - 1827 Words

Oliver Stone’s 1994 classic, Natural Born Killers, excited and traumatized its audiences while also causing controversy. The tale of white trash lovers caught up in a realm of chaos that includes a continuous murderous rampage from state to state, draws in audiences with its graphic violence and riveting pulse inducing music. Yet, the message of this film seems to be much deeper than just exposing audiences to yet another chaotic action movie filled with guns, blood and mayhem. Stone’s Natural Born Killers examines the subject of media’s investment in serial murder very thoroughly, and so it seems likely that it has the potential to offer a more rigorous interrogation of the nature of the American public’s fascination with the serial†¦show more content†¦The film is so surreal, disorienting, and consistently disturbing that the viewer, mortified by the wild, intoxicating spectacle it reveals to him, is left feeling like a drunk who, having committ ed some terrible deed, realizes what he has done only when he subsequently looks in dismay at the grisly effects of his actions (Sweeney 156). Not only is Natural Born Killers is a uniquely-directed feature, because of the wide-range of camera angles, filters, lenses and special effects used during its production but it also films much of the film in what seems to be told from a television-perspective. The varied aspects of the film that are done in this â€Å"television-perspective† or â€Å"media vision† bring out the grittiness of the plot. Often time scenes are either in black and white or in what sometimes resembles Technicolor. It makes the audience feel as though they are either watching a documentary or the news for that matter. Some scenes in Natural Born Killers are satirical of television shows of the time, including a serious-scene which is told in the farce of a situational comedy about a dysfunctional-family. These scenes in Natural Born Killers display the often talked about elements of what makes a serial killer. For instance, studies have shown that serial killers are often the products of bad childhoods. They are either mentally or physically abused, outsiders socially and presumably murder or mameShow MoreRelated Pointless Violence in the Movie (Film), Natural Born Killers566 Words   |  3 PagesPointless Violence in the Movie (Film), Natural Born Killers Daily, the public is bombarded with violence, not only on television, but also in other media, such as newspapers and tabloids. Natural Born Killers, a prime example of violence in the media, is a movie about two lovers, Mickey and Mallory Knox, who go on a killing spree across the Southwest. The movie takes a satirical look at how the media romanticizes violent crimes. Natural Born Killers has sparked a lot of controversy, as seenRead MoreNatural Born Killers And The Film Stars Woody Harrelson And Juliette Lewis1636 Words   |  7 PagesFor my film project I chose, Natural Born Killers, (1994) the film stars Woody Harrelson and Juliette Lewis as the notorious couple Mickey and Mallory Knox. The film follows Knox’s on their cross-country murder spree that captivates the world as the media glorifies their crimes making them the most infamous serial killers since Manson. Natural Born Killers starts out in a small diner in the middle of the desert, Mickey is ordering pie and Mallory is dancing to a jukebox, a couple of locals enterRead MoreNatural Born Killers Essay1372 Words   |  6 PagesDiego Stehle Audio-visual Language Module 1: Assigment essay August 19/2008 Natural Born Killers Mallory Knox (Juliette Lewis) is an abused teenage daughter from an awful family. She meets Mickey Knox (Woody Harrelson), a butcher ´s son, when he delivers fifty pounds of beef to her house; love is instant and inevitable. Mallory ´s father did not approve their relationship and sends Mickey to jail. After escaping, Mickey goes to save Mallory from her parents by killing them and this is howRead MoreAnalysis of Natural Born Killers Essay989 Words   |  4 PagesAnalysis of Natural Born Killers Natural born killers is a violent film with a twist. It provides humor and violence and cartoons in parts of the film. I think that Natural born killers is a bad film because a lot of the time you don’t know what is going on and it is a film that you have to watch without any distractions, also it makes out that violence is funny by using cartoons and other surrealistic parts. The film is also bad because it can influence dominant andRead MoreThe Influence of Exposure to Violence627 Words   |  3 Pageslike Bok have provoked thought over the negative effects of the media’s relentless coverage of violence. In a film written by Quentin Tarantino titled Natural Born Killers, Tarantino portrays the role of the media, which in turn delivers the very effects of violent exposure that Bok is critical of. Though ironic, Tarantino’s Natural Born Killer aims to elicit thought, as to serve as a mirror to the current culture of media and violence. The film portrays violence found in media and its glamorizationRead Moreâ€Å"You Can’t Hide from Your Shadow† - Should Natural Born Killers Be Banned?1604 Words   |  7 Pagesâ€Å"You Can’t Hide From Your Shadow† Should Natural Born Killers be Banned? In 1994 a film was released that sent religious groups, politicians and the sensationalist media into a fever; Natural Born Killers was â€Å"a bold new film that takes a look at a country seduced by fame, obsessed by crime and consumed by the media.† through the tale of two young murderers. In the years that followed the film was blamed for scores of tragedies in America, including but not limited to the case of a boy whoRead More Horror Movies Essay660 Words   |  3 Pages nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â€Å"Natural Born Killers,† â€Å" Psycho,† â€Å" Friday the 13th ,† and â€Å"The Legend of Sleepy Hollow† are all horror films. In these films there is always some crazy person or monster-like character that goes around and slaughters innocent people. And usually, but not all the time the killer is killed at the end of the movie. The media publishes or broadcasts stories that say that horror films influence people to imitate these wrongful acts of violence. I believe that theseRead MoreLE300J Final Essay1628 Words   |  7 PagesLE300J Serial Killers as Heroes in Popular Culture Professor Donna Strong Park University Throughout time many have had a fascination with serial killers and with help from the media they have become celebrities within our culture. There are many books, movies, television shows, and news coverage to introduce viewers to their lives. With all the interest behind serial killers, many wonder how they come to be this violent. The question is often asked, are serial killers born or made? Read MoreThe Similarity of Bollywood Films to High Concept American Films1097 Words   |  5 Pagesâ€Å"Titanic†, â€Å"Home Alone† and â€Å"Star wars.† Most blockbuster films are high concept and have A list actors. In the well known film, â€Å"Natural Born Killers†, there are actors of which we are familiar with (Tommy Lee Jones and Woody Howard) this attracts the audience to the film if they know what to expect from the actors. Natural Born Killers has been distributed worldwide and sold a huge number of copies everywhere especially America, unlike the Bollywood film, â€Å"ArmaanRead MoreEssay Are Serial Killers Born or Made?1560 Words   |  7 PagesEvidence that was gathered from books such as â€Å"Inside the Minds of Mass Murderers† and â€Å"Inside the Minds of Serial Killers,† both written by Kathertine Ramsland, provide information and evidence that killers are in fact made, not born. Some of the reasons that people believe that killers are made and not born are due to research by many psychiatrists on serial killers and mass murderers who are on death roe that have committed some of the most heinous crimes. One argument is that there is a set of

Equal Opportunity Evolves Human Resources - 1671 Words

EQUAL OPPORTUNITY EVOLVES HUMAN RESOURCES The predominant founder of the civil rights movement of the 1960s, Martin Luther King, stated, â€Å"All progress is precarious, and the solution of one problem brings us face-to-face with another problem† (Mathis 2006). We daily witness the famed Civil Rights Act of 1964 evolve to challenge and change human resource policies and procedures to meet the increased complexity and awareness of human resources. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) was created by Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964; however, the Commission’s mission has been shaped by more than this one single piece of legislation. Numerous laws, amendments, and executive orders have expanded, limited or guided the†¦show more content†¦Over the years these regulations have changed with the consciousness of the people and the technologies of the day. Imperfect? Yes, but with increased education and research into the needs of individuals and evolving forms of work and organizations , the culture overall has demanded more equitable employment practices, locally and nationally. I prefer fewer laws that perpetuate external motivation for fairness, looking to the day when individuals increasingly become internally led in their behavior. To that end, I selected three federal regulations that seem to me to lead to that increased individual and family strength (however we define family today) that collectively builds and sustains creative efforts for quality living in balanced work and life settings. First, the Civil Rights Act of 1964 Title VII states â€Å"it is illegal for employers to discriminate with respect to terms, conditions, or privileges of employment because of race, religion, ethnics†¦Ã¢â‚¬  (age, gender, sexual orientation were added later) (EEOC). Let us examine the major advantages and disadvantages of this huge legal step that took on the challenge of eradicating exploitation of workers. One area of concern to me is hostile environments, an a rea this act is designed to eliminate or minimize. Rita Byrnes Kittle, EEOC Supervisory Trial Attorney, Denver Field Office (Kittle) gives an in-depth clarification of a hostile work environment, stating such anShow MoreRelatedThe Fundamental Economic Principles1809 Words   |  7 Pages Part 1 Scarcity When humans moved from hunter/gatherer societies to villages and then cities, a division of labor occurred. Some people became producers of food, some processors, some the ancillary goods and services that are necessary for humans to live together. They found that sometimes there was a surplus of goods, and sometimes a lack of goods. This lack of goods is called the scarcity principle, and it is the fundamental economic principle of needing (or wanting) goods in a world that hasRead MoreLiberalism Is The Root Of Our American Soil Essay1217 Words   |  5 Pagesaction works to achieve equal opportunity and equalities for every individual in our society. The government’s duty presented here is to â€Å"alleviate social ills, to protect civil liberties, and protect individuals and human rights.† The government’s crucial role in a liberalistic society is to guarantee that no one is in need, and that liberal policies stress the need for the government to solve problems. From an egalitarian sense, liberalism focuses on attaining more equal distributions of incomeRead MoreWorking At T Corporate Office1706 Words   |  7 PagesWorking at the ATT corporate office located in Englewood, Colorado made it pretty easy to ask our Human Resource representative if she could spend a few minutes answering questions for my school project. She is a great reflection on how the employees are to work with at ATT. I learned that you have to be willing to go lateral sometimes to be able to climb the career ladder. Also learned that being union you are in a very structured environment. That made me curious of what the future is for theRead MoreItm533 It Project, Logistics, and Contract Management1215 Words   |  5 Pagessets are the same. This is the project manager’s blessing and curse. Given the 14 Key Principles for Project Management Success (Greer 1999), no two project managers will interpret these principles the same, nor will they execute their duties with equal skill. I will demonstrate the art of project management as I step through these 14 Key Principles. Project managers must focus on three dimensions of project success. With these three dimensions including time, budget, and quality we imply thereRead MoreThe Key Functions Of The Human Resource Management895 Words   |  4 Pagesfunctions of the human resource management (HR) department that support the health care field the most are: motivating healthcare employees, demographic and diversity trends, and information systems in the field. (ncbi.nlm.nih) If an organization is unable to provide a work environment that motivates its staff to perform to their maximum potential, staff will gravitate to another organization. Healthcare organizations must value their staff by providing professional training opportunities that allowRead MoreRobert Nozick s History And The Constitution Of The Nation1227 Words   |  5 Pagesindividual’s right and is therefore unjust. Nozick also takes his minimal state concept and uses it to criticize and discredit the ideas of Rawl’s theo ry of justice and the concept of a social contract. According to John Rawl, justice and equal opportunities are the two most important social concepts needed in order to establish an orderly society. Rawl’s theory of justice proposed an imaginary argumentative situation, which dominated social life since its origins. From this stand point individualsRead MoreEssay on Human resources1700 Words   |  7 PagesHuman resources Human resources is concerned with the employees who work for the organisation. Wise organisations regard staff as the most important resources. Other resources include money, equipment, buildings, land and, materials, however, if the employees are not motivated and only do the minimum work that us requires, then all the money or equipment in the world won’t make the business successful. On the other hand if the employees are keen to do their best, are well trained and committedRead MoreThe Idea Of Intellectual Property864 Words   |  4 Pagestendency to tie intellectual property with the marketplace of ideas. The key argument arises whether ideas- intangible resources, can be protected as property using the same concepts and social processes that protect tangible property. The concept of property stems from scarcity. Which is, the basic economic problem that results from people having unlimited wants but limited resources. Scarcity doesn’t explicitly mean unattainable or nonexistent, only that supply is limited or restricted to some extentRead MoreGlobalization And The Global World1669 Words   |  7 Pagesin front of your face. Everywhere our head turns, commercialism is there. It is unavoidable. The world around us is constantly developing, and that development begins with us. As the world keeps evolving, globalization is considered inevitable. As humans, we naturally strive for success, seeking to better ourselves on an individual l evel and our environment on a global scale. In order to do so, there is a need to familiarize and connect to one another so humanity can flourish together. This essayRead MoreA Definite Link Between an Organisations Business Strategy and Human Resources Strategy Is Essential for Business Success1207 Words   |  5 PagesA Definite Link Between an Organisation s Business Strategy and Human Resources Strategy is Essential for Business Success The world of work as we know it today is changing rapidly from the introduction of new labour laws, globalisation, demographics, an ageing workforce. In the busy and demanding environments in which people work today it s not very often that we can take the opportunity to step back and look at the broader picture and overall direction in which we are heading. There are many

Different Levels of Devolution to Be Found in Northern Ireland free essay sample

The history of these isles, which we call Great Britain and Ireland, has produced a peculiar and unique situation of governance throughout the nations of which the islands consist. England, as largest and most populous territory in the region, has been the dominant power for centuries; annexing or merging with the Celtic nations of Wales, Scotland and Ireland between 1536 and 1800. Following the independence of the Irish Free State and partition of the island of Ireland, we have the country that is known today as The United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland as well as the independent Irish Republic. Over the course of this essay I will examine the different levels of devolution to be found within Britain and Ireland, identifying similarities and differences between the types of devolution granted at present as well as possibilities for further devolution of power. Within the United Kingdom, power has been devolved from Westminster to the outlying capitals of Belfast, Edinburgh and Cardiff in different ways, according to a region’s particular characteristics and idiosyncrasies. However devolution, described as â€Å"a limited form of decentralisation† (Grant, 2009), has been seen as giving power over their own affairs back to the people of each of the smaller nations, who in many cases may have felt some sense of marginalisation by rule from London. This being the case, there are certainly aspects of devolved power which have been granted to Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland with little variance. Administrative devolution has occurred in all three territories, with local government being given authority over running services, allocating funds and organising administration. Practically this means that areas such as Health, Education, Housing and other areas are equally the domain of each outlying government throughout the UK. With this fact acknowledged, one can then examine other â€Å"devolved government arrangements †¦ that are markedly asymmetrical† (Jeffrey amp; Wincott, 2006). Of the three nations with devolved powers at present, Wales is the one which has least expressed desires for separation or independence; this despite a strong sense of Welsh cultural and national pride, with the flourishing Welsh language as a focal point and a Welsh nationalist party in Plaid Cymru. Indeed the 1997 devolution referendum in Wales, pushed by the Labour government, was passed by a mere 7,000 votes, with only 50% voter turnout. The tiny margin of victory despite government support along with the low turnout figures suggests an antipathy, certainly at the time of the referendum, amongst the Welsh electorate towards the idea of self-governance and devolution. This fact, along with the view that Wales as a nation is most inextricably linked with England, has resulted in Wales agreeing to a low level of devolution with the Welsh Assembly. The sixty member Welsh Assembly which was set up in the wake of the 1997 referendum has been described as a â€Å"strange anatomy† (Rawlings, 2003). The Assembly has control over the spending and allocation of the Welsh budget, as handed down by Westminster, but with no taxation or primary law-making powers (Grant, 2009). However, the introduction of devolution in Wales does seem to have reinvigorated the public debate over transfer of powers. By 2003, the preferred option (38% from four options) amongst the Welsh people was clearly for more devolution powers, in the form of a Welsh Parliament (Wales, 2006). Scotland has achieved a different, more extensive form of devolution than Wales; not least due to the fact that it is much bigger physically and in terms of population as well as being further geographically removed from London. However the rise of support in Scotland for a devolved form of administration in the 1980s and 1990s coincided with a number of factors which either increased self-confidence as a Scottish nation or else disaffection with the Westminster government. The main reason for rising nationalist sentiment was the monopoly on power in Britain which was held by the Conservatives over the course of most of these decades, despite having very little support north of the border. The Tories put in place a number of policies which were deeply unpopular in Scotland such as the Poll Tax and the closure of the shipyards and other industries. The discovery of North Sea oil, as well as membership of a European Union that was booming by the 1990s also gave many Scots’ confidence in their ability to manage their own affairs. As such, the referendum of 1997 was a huge endorsement of devolution with almost three quarters of voters in favour of devolving power to Edinburgh and 60% approving tax varying powers (Pattie, Denver, Mitchell, amp; Botchel, 1998). While some state functions such as defence, foreign affairs and overall fiscal policy are reserved by Westminster, the ability to vary taxes is one of a number of key contrasts between the devolved administrations in Cardiff and Edinburgh. As well as the ability to vary taxes by up to 3 pence on the pound, the Scottish government also takes responsibility for justice, policing and administration of certain EU laws within Scotland, among other roles. Today we can see the apparent success of this devolution in the eyes of the Scottish people with the debate switching from devolution to independence, with the Scottish National Party amongst the chief advocates of an independent Scotland. While polls seem to show that full independence remains unlikely in the time scale offered, â€Å"[t]he real option here is option three ‘devo max’† (Jenkins, 2012) for most Scottish voters. Such an option would give Scotland full fiscal autonomy as well as power over nearly all aspects of Scottish life. If included as an option in a referendum, devo max would appear to be the preferred option for a majority of the Scottish electorate. Northern Ireland is a unique situation due to the widely documented history of sustained conflict between the two major, broad religious/political groupings of Protestants/unionists and Catholics/nationalists. The legacy of ‘The Troubles’ has been a deeply divided society which has remained the case up to the present day, with â€Å"segregation still exist[ing] across politics, schooling, housing and education. † (Nolan, 2012) However, following the Belfast Agreement in 1998 and the successful referendum endorsing the peace process, a Northern Ireland Assembly and Executive were formed in 1999. The distinctive political dimensions in Northern Ireland mean that â€Å"many of the features of Northern Ireland devolution follow consociational models† (Jeffrey C. 2009), in other words many of the features of the Northern Ireland Assembly and Executive are in place in order to manage conflict between the two broad groupings existent in Northern Ireland. As majority rule cannot be considered, Northern Ireland uses the d’Hondt system whereby power in the Executive is divided on a highest averages basis and the number of seats on the Executive controlled by a party corresponds to the amount of assembly seats gained, â€Å"thereby realising the proportionality principle which is one of the underpinning characteristics of consociational democracy† (Wilford, 2009). Now that security concerns have subsided so that Justice powers can be devolved (currently under the stewardship of cross community Alliance Party) Northern Ireland’s Executive has authority over its own affairs to a greater extent than Wales but perhaps not so much power as that of Alex Salmond’s Scottish government. While the Executive in Northern Ireland does have the power to pass, amend or repeal laws directly related to the region (which Wales does not) it does not have the same level of fiscal control as that of Scotland. Recently there have been calls from both unionist and nationalist parties for greater control of fiscal powers, particularly regarding the rate of corporation tax – the rate is much higher in the UK than in the Republic of Ireland. While in recent years the devolved system at Stormont seems a cause for optimism, one must recognise that â€Å"[a]ny appraisal of devolution in Northern Ireland over the past decade has first to acknowledge that it has been a disjointed affair. † (Wilford, 2009) Indeed Stormont was suspended from 2002-2007, however it is hoped that the current session will allow Northern Ireland to make progress as a devolved region. The two previously unmentioned territories in the region, namely England and the Republic of Ireland, are different in that they each host the capital city of a sovereign nation. While this may suggest that the appetite for devolution would not exist in the two countries, proposals involving some degree of decentralisation have been suggested. The Republic of Ireland had an overall population of less than 4. 6 million as of 2011, with around two fifths of all citizens living in the Greater Dublin area. These facts, coupled with Ireland’s relatively small size geographically, would not offer any great comfort for proponents of devolved government. However the more realistic debate in the Republic had been the decentralisation of government departments to various cities and towns throughout the state. Indeed government plans to spread the wealth and jobs created in Dublin were underway from as early as 2003, â€Å"10,300 public servants, including the headquarters of eight departments, were to be dispersed from the capital to 3 locations in every other county in the State† (McDonald, 2011) However the plan was shelved soon thereafter, due to the diseconomies of scale and co-ordination problems that such a decentralising plan would entail, but at an overall cost to the taxpayer of â‚ ¬338 million on costs such as the acquisition and development of sites that were never to be used. The evidence from the plan would seem to suggest that decentralisation, and certainly de volution, would be unsuitable in the Irish Republic. England, on the other hand, is by far the largest and most populous country on the islands constituting Britain and Ireland with a population of over 50 million and, when taken as a country subdivision, ranks number one globally in terms of GDP. England’s capital city of London also serves as capital for the greater United Kingdom, perhaps a major factor in the view that â€Å"the English think that Westminster should have most control over them† (Jeffrey C. , 2009) in contrast to the people of Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland. Attempts at some form of regional, elected government within England were comprehensively rejected when 78% of the electorate in the North East of the country voted ‘No’ in a referendum on the implementation of such government in 2004 (Grant, 2009). The results of that ballot seem to have removed the issue of English devolution from the agenda for the foreseeable future. Perhaps the major issue involving England and the topic of devolution is what has become known as the ‘West Lothian Question,’ regarding â€Å"inequities of representation of the Scots and English after devolution† (Jeffrey C. 2009). Due to the autonomy that has come with devolution, Scottish MPs have law making powers over areas of English policy due to UK-wide Westminster being England’s only form of government. English MPs, on the other hand, have no powers over Scotland in the areas that have been devolved; leading to what former Conservative leader Iain Duncan Smith called a â€Å"democratic monstrosity† (Carrell, 2012) From the evidence gathered I feel confident in concluding that devolution has generally been a success in the UK. While the divergent characteristics of each region necessitate asymmetrical devolution of powers to Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland it seems to be an adaptable process with further devolution powers possible in each of the three territories. Scotland, as a larger country with more aspirations towards self-sufficiency, has clearly been afforded a greater level of devolved power than the Welsh, who presently seem content with a low level form of devolved government. Northern Ireland’s exceptional circumstances as a post conflict region have of course called for a different approach to devolved government. With the apparent stabilisation of the region in recent years, calls for increased fiscal powers and a better functioning Executive offer optimistic signs of progress. England, and certainly the Republic of Ireland, would not seem to offer fertile ground for any such devolved administration in the foreseeable future.